Went to that place I haven’t been in years. Not since that thing happened. I found a locked box I vaguely recognized. As luck (or misfortune) would have it, my foot kicked something that went ringing across the floor… a small brass key.
Chunks of my brain lit up with warning signals, heart rate went crazy and I started sweating like a slug. But the idiot that I am, I opened it anyway.
There was only one other person in the world who could have interpreted what I found inside. Now there’s only me. There’s no point in writing what I found, because it wouldn’t make sense to anyone. But from my reaction you might’ve guessed it was a freshly severed head. Memory is the cruellest thing I’ve ever known. Memory is responsible for all of us being here, all our pains, one way or another. Blessed are the lobotomized.
9 comments
I always wanted to say that i liked your username, but i’m not sure if i ever mentioned it.
Also, this post reminded me of an article i read… maybe a year or more ago, about a “forgetting pill” (afaik still not available) meant to help people who have been traumatized by events, and the memories thereof.
i love your username
Thanks guys, I actually spent a long time coming up with that and immediately thinking it was stupid…
A forgetting pill… Would you take it?
Surprisingly I don’t think I would, as much as it would take away the pain. The real cure is suicide. Anything less is a cheap compromise. I feel like someone who’s suffering from an incurable, painful disease. Rather than dope myself on painkillers for the last pathetic years of my life I’ll take the pain because it’ll force me to end it all.
I had to come dig this up after today.
How ironic that the day after you post this, i find myself in a neighborhood i didn’t expect or realize i’d be in… which did something to me that must have resembled, in some ways, your experience with the box.
As for the forgetting pill…
I would probably try it. I doubt it could make me forget entire people, but i would gladly erase a pile of the right (or wrong, perspective…) memories, if it would ensure i would not feel the pains (and their subsequently overwhelming disruptive capacity) associated with them again. Perhaps with less memory-torture, i’d be able to fix some things.
Hey CN, I hope you survived the memory ambush. Does it help to talk about it? With me it doesn’t really, but I figured I’d ask if you wanted to try to purge some bad brain cells.
That’s an interesting and noble take on the memory pill. You’re absolutely right… if you consider that we are crippled by memory, unable to function, then for the sake of functioning properly (to fix things) we should take the pill.
A story hit the news today which disgusted me to the core because it reminded me of something that happened to me. My gut reaction was to contact the victim and help them get justice. But then I said, who am I kidding, I couldn’t even get justice for myself. So I took a bunch of sleeping pills and I intend to be unconscious for the rest of the day.
This course of action doesn’t help anyone. It doesn’t fix anything, it doesn’t make the world a better place, it doesn’t champion the rights of the oppressed, yadda yadda. But I have no choice because, due to those disruptive capacity pains you mentioned, I am reduced to being powerless.
A pill to make me forget my trauma, while not fixing the trauma, would help me function so I could help others.
But then would I still have the desire to help others if I didn’t remember my tragedy? Probably not.
Maybe you can’t win either way.
Idk. I’m still swimming in aftershocks, i think. My whole day has been surreal. I slept more today than i have in a while.
The memory pill… i would be conflicted about it, due to the need to forget some things (and someone) that i would rather remember. But since all i have are the memories, and all they do is hurt me, while the lessons learned can’t be applied to anything in my actual life… “the right thing to do,” would be to alleviate myself from needless suffering, and take it, and forget those things.
I can’t even watch the news these days. I honestly don’t want to know, unless it’s going to directly impact me. It’s not that i don’t care; it’s that i do care, but i don’t want to. Plus, “the news” just opens a whole can of worms i get tired of being force-fed.
I would recommend reading the article (the one i found was on ‘wired’). They intend to make it precise enough that you might still “know it happened,” but not actually remember the traumatizing parts.
But you’re right to question whether the motivation to help others would still exist, without the hardships we’ve experienced. My answer is “perhaps not.” I’m not sure we wouldn’t still want to help, nor am i sure we would. I think there is some humanist, naturalist morality at play here, in which we must understand the value of the experience of suffering, to be motivated to avoid, reduce, and possibly eliminate it, as well as how important it is for all of us to work toward that goal, for the sake of the greater good. It’s easy to inadvertently cross over from “realism” to “idealism,” on this topic.
Basically, if only some of us are working toward elimination of needless suffering, while “the rest of most people” either don’t care, or don’t get it, or even actively oppose such efforts… then is it even “worth trying?” In the face of overwhelming resistance, is “morality” even possible? Is it “useful” or “beneficial” to ourselves and the rest of the world? Or is it just an idealistic fantasy, another “false construct” through which to filter our perceptions of the world, ourselves, so that we can make things seem like what we want them to be, despite the overwhelming evidence to suggest that things are not, and will never be, the ways we wish they were?
Often, i know what i am inclined to think, but not sure what to say. There is just so much that seems should not need saying, but seems to need saying, anyway. It seems “life” is arbitrarily saturated with artificial and diversionary requirements to surpass seemingly boundless obfuscation, in order to even reach the real issues, to begin observing, evaluating, analyzing, and ultimately, crafting solutions.
Meanwhile, tick tock, days, weeks, months, years lost…
I feel like i need a group, a community, from which to organize a unified front against the problems i see… but all “those like me” seem to be sporadically scattered throughout the world, unable to come together to accomplish anything, if we can even locate each other at all.
A horrible thought occurred to me.
I imagined “waking up” after a successful forgetting-pill-session, only find a mysterious feeling that something was “missing,” and to then embark upon a quest to discover what no one would reveal to me.
Ultimately, i bite and scratch and claw and fight to regain those same memories i had just fought so hard to erase.
I swear i have seen at least two different movies with that same trope. But ironically, i can’t seem to remember what they were. lol.
That would be my luck. The pill wouldn’t work correctly, would erase too much or leave a lingering trigger, and i’d end up in some bad sci-fi-horror trope, fighting to regain traumatizing memories i intentionally lost. Antagonizing all the people who i feel have turned against me, who are actually just trying to help me, who knew what i needed to forget, and why i wanted not to remember.
In the end… i have nothing but the knowledge of what i needed to forget, and have alienated everyone who cared.
Omg you’ve just given voice to all the bizarre thoughts I’ve had swirling in my head for years but never had the ability to pin down, much less express.
First, movies (the fun stuff). Immediately I’m reminded of Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. I won’t ruin it in case you haven’t seen it (in fact I don’t even remember how it ends), but the plot is exactly like what you described.
I do believe it would happen exactly as you predicted. Or even if you were unable to find the purged memories, your life would probably repeat the same course and fill the empty traumas with new ones. This would happen ESPECIALLY if you have compassion for others and are bothered by suffering in the world. We all know there’s no shortage of that, so your empty memory cells would just soak up a new tragedy.
So for example, if you’re traumatized by the loss of a loved one and you somehow manage to have the memory scrubbed clean, it would just be a matter of time before you lose another loved one and experience the same pain all over again, as if that pain is reserved for you.
I have a bum shoulder. I’m told it will never be 100%. Even after surgery and careful exercise and all that crap, all it takes is a good whack in the wrong direction and it comes apart again. I think memories are a lot like flesh and ligaments. The doc can fix me up and make my shoulder “forget” that it was ever injured, but it will always be a matter of time before it happens all over.
Which takes me to the philosophical stuff you brought up. Why are some of us prone to feel the world’s suffering? Why do some of us have weak shoulders?
I once thought it was part of a cosmic plan. Not necessarily God, but just a natural order of things, the way nature supplies different organisms for all the necessary functions of the planet. People (and animals) who care serve a purpose. They are sort of the guardians of life, the way white blood cells are the guardians of red blood cells.
Wouldn’t it be awesome to be an ordinary red blood cell. Your daily routine would be something like: Woke up, went to lung, picked up oxygen, dropped it off in brain, phew another busy day.
And wouldn’t it suck to be a white blood cell? Woke up, heard red blood cells in distress, threw on cape, went and kicked some flu virus ass, oh no there’s the distress signal again, will it ever end??
Well my friend, if you find yourself constantly bothered by injustice in the world, by the innocent being preyed upon, then chances are you’re a white blood cell. I happen to be a particularly sucky one because I can’t get off my ass to help anyone anymore. Which leads us full circle in the discussion. When you find yourself exhausted & beaten & useless, can you heal yourself by forgetting the past? Or have you just reached the end of your useful life, whether or not you have those memories?
That’s a really good post. I rather like the blood cell analogy, and found your explanation of “a day in the life of blood cell” amusing. 🙂