I disagree. Who says that we are all beyond repair? Perhaps there are a few of us who deserve better than the misery we live in. Give them the chance we were deprived of
Suicidal people attempting to help other suicidal people, could be likened to the phrase: “the blind leading the blind.” The blind do not help each other “see,” but they can help each other to better cope with blindness… probably better than any sighted person could.
It’s the same with suicidal depression. A typical “happy person with few problems” is not going to understand suicidal depression well enough to help a suicidally depressed person to better cope with it; because the “happy people” do not understand it.
Some of us do “care” about the world, and the people in it… but many of us are incredibly bitter, jaded, cynical, /because of/ the world, and the people in it.
Your insinuative premise is that A) we don’t care, and B) not caring makes us “bad” … and that is both inaccurate and offensive.
It’s as if people think it’s okay to insult us for not caring about what those who cause us problems, demand we “care about.”
There is “a point” in caring about others. It’s just not one that’s easily explained. And it doesn’t matter whether or not there is “any point.” Caring doesn’t require a purpose. Likewise, suicide doesn’t mean we don’t care. It means we can’t deal with the way things are, knowing we can’t change it.
I’ll agree on the “save yourself” part, though.
Who would ever want to live a life in which you always need someone to “save” you? The self is the only one who can save the self.
With the semi exception that i’m not so much “offended” but have pity – i believe the original poster is projecting his/her own feelings more than accurately describing the general attitude of the folks here.
I think a lot of people around here may care too much about others, their opinions and their actions and don’t focus on their own well being as much as they should.
Thanks Dawg. I actually agree with what you said about not “being offended,” but instead feeling a sense of pity.
There’s a subtle but important distinction to be made, here, in that, while i’m saying something “is offensive,” that doesn’t necessarily mean that “i feel offended.” Imagine Dr. Spock stating that he finds something inaccurate and offensive. I meant it in a more… clinical, vulcan, observational way. And i do often pity those who commit an offense borne of ignorance. Doing things that upset people, just because you don’t know any better, is pretty sad. Doing things that upset people, because you /don’t care to know/ any better, is “offensive.” I realize this is a quite common occurrence, and so unless it’s something serious, i rarely take it personally… though i still like to point out that certain things “are offensive,” so that, perhaps the person wants to know that, and will learn something, and choose to act differently in the future. Or, they will blatantly reject the lesson, drawing the line between us, and identifying themselves as someone who does not want to learn. And no one has time for people who don’t want to learn. While it’s tempting, i have no time for being personally offended by such offenses. I usually just chalk it up to “that’s just how people are,” frown in disappointment, shrug, and move on.
I’ve been feeling very frustrated lately. I’m seeing lots of evidence of a misguidance pandemic. I mean… i guess i always knew it was there, but ‘here’ it’s emphasized. It’s just more reinforcement for my very generalized theory that “misguidance leads to increased suffering.”
I couldn’t agree more with your hypothesis here – I know from first hand experience … thankfully I had my epiphany on how to view things from a perspective that centers around me but yet has compassion for others provided they at least respond with a base level of respect, honor and civility – if they don’t, i refuse to internalize it (a point where many people go off the rails) – i simply reject and ignore the ungrateful folks and walk away without another thought or concern
in other words, don’t let negative people rent space in your head
Also, another important epiphany was that “Forgiveness” is most important for me than it ever will be for those i “give” it to. But way too many people hoard forgiveness like it’s gold bricks that people don’t deserve … and that might be true if forgiveness was more important for others than it is for self … but it really isn’t that way at all. But that concept runs counter to everything most of us have been taught all our lives thus making it difficult to “flip the script” on how forgiveness actually works.
Anyway – a lot of philosophies and view can be better understood in my posts and comments … you can lead a horse to water …
You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make it think? Is that how it goes? 🙂
I like the analogy of the blind leading the blind. Imagine getting directions on the street from a blind man, if you were lost, blind, and in unfamiliar territory. I suppose it’s possible the other blind man could help you find your way, but ultimately you’ll have to stumble along and figure it for yourself.
In order to respond to your statement, we must first consider what being suicidal means. Not everyone here is suicidal and if they are, not everyone is suicidal all of the time. I believe that to be suicidal you must actively be seeking out a way to die and it is your intention for this to be carried out within a reasonable amount of time. In my opinion, a person like that is going to be too preoccupied with ending their own life than saving someone else. This does not necessarily mean that they want to assist others in dying or that they are incapable of caring for other people. It does not prevent them from making helpful comments or giving advice. Those that contemplate suicide are not always selfish in doing so (there have been many posts on this).
Once you have established what being suicidal is, you then have to consider whether a person deemed suicidal can be helped online. Suicide hotlines exist for a reason. People standing on the edge of tall buildings or with a gun to their head have been talked down. A forum like this (or at least the way it was before the new mods took over) can help distract a suicidal person long enough for their state of mind to alter or circumstances that brought them here to change. Which leads me on to another point; what is help? They believe they are helping by deleting posts when in fact if anything it has the opposite affect. I’ll come back to power, authority and personal benefit in the next paragraph. People generally overemphasise the help you get or receive online but it would be unfair to say it hasn’t saved at least one person’s life.
Going back to what I said about suicidal people giving help, it’s appropriate to consider peoples motives. Why do people offer help. If a non-suicidal person offers help because they somehow gain the kind of gratification you get from saving the world or doing a good deed or because they like making friends then it is mutually beneficial. Similarly, a suicidal person can benefit by offering to help somebody else. It’s not just about the benefit derived from receiving support but the sense of purpose in thinking you’ve made someones life better or made a friend.
Of course, nobody has all the answers and that doesn’t depend on whether you are suicidal or not. I know plenty of stupid people who have never been suicidal and I’d never follow there advice on anything. Equally, you aren’t always going to get a high quality response to your post that makes you think or makes you feel. There are also plenty of non-suicidal’s that have absolutely no regard for anyone except themselves.
People are suicidal for different reasons. The reasons as well as their personality and experience will determine the extent to which they are able to take advantage of the support they give or receive.
I disagree with the “blind leading the blind” analogy fundamentally … this analogy assume everyone has the same problem … that is fundamentally incorrect … everyone has a similar symptom to a problem – depression/suicidal …. but they arrived there from vastly different root issues … in other words they are not all “blind” as it were.
now if we were to say something like “the handicapped leading the handicapped”, that would be infinitely more accurate since that would include every handicap across the spectrum – including, but not limited to, the blind. In this context – the varied handicaps can be a hindrance to some but they’d still have abilities that a differently handicapped person did not.
The problem comes when the blind person does not ask the sighted but legless person for assistance – if you willfully reject the assistance from those who are able or who may otherwise have insight, your chance to move forward becomes much more difficult if not impossible … so …
you can lead a horse to water … but you can’t make him think or drink or anything else … it is now and always has been the choice of the “horse” as to his direction
I disagree too. Suicidal people can, and are strongly willing, to help others like them. The fact of the matter is that those who have not seen the dark side, and experienced it themselves, can not help them. They have no clue how to relate to what they feel or how they think. I find it easier to talk to someone who’s suicidal like I am than to someone who thinks they know what I’m talking about because they read that story or saw that movie. When I talk to people who aren’t like me, they always say, “Stay strong!!! It’ll get better if you just try harder.” But people who understand what I’m going through talk to me about what’s happening and give me advice that actually helps.
.
There will be people (note, not all) who are [truly] suicidal and where their mind has reached that state where ‘committing suicide’ is perceived as being ‘necessary’ — in which state they will not have the psychological (/ emotional) wherewithal / capacity to _care_ for others… A lot of _suicides_ ( and those which have been thoroughly contemplated [ as deemed so by the individual, within their ‘capacity’ ] ) will have as an integral component the sense (‘understanding’ [according to the individual’s processing], even) that the ‘world’ has ‘failed’ them … even that no one is truly concerned about / cares for them ( ‘hence’ “there is no point in caring for others… save yourself”).
I’m not saying that everyone’s depression is the same, i’m saying that someone with the same problem is most likely to understand how to cope with it, whereas someone who does not understand that problem, cannot. The blind can lead the blind through their blindness, better than can the sighted. The deaf can lead the deaf through their deafness, better than those who hear.
Your interpretation seems to assume that “all depression is blindness” when that is not what i was saying, nor the point of the analogy. I just thought there was an apt comparison to a long-established phrase. Person with problem-A is likely more capable of helping another person with problem-A, than someone who cannot understand problem-A as someone who has experienced it, can.
The reason “the blind leading the blind” was relevant, and is a better descriptor than the overly-generalized “handicapped leading the handicapped,” is because of the specificity. There are copious different types and degrees of “handicapped.” Whose to say one “handicapped” understands another, of an entirely different nature? That was the point. People with /the same problem/ are more likely to understand each other, and be better able to help each other cope. “Suicidal depression” in this case is a sort of blanket term… but is similar enough that even when it occurs for different reasons, the experience of it is quite similar, as opposed to, say, a blind person versus a quadriplegic. People with the same or similar problems, are better able to understand and assist each other, due to knowledge that only those who experience those problems, will have.
Sometimes, the blind need help that only the sighted can give. In this case, i was referring to help that only another blind person would be able to give, because the sighted cannot “truly understand” the experience of blindness.
13 comments
I disagree. Who says that we are all beyond repair? Perhaps there are a few of us who deserve better than the misery we live in. Give them the chance we were deprived of
Suicidal people attempting to help other suicidal people, could be likened to the phrase: “the blind leading the blind.” The blind do not help each other “see,” but they can help each other to better cope with blindness… probably better than any sighted person could.
It’s the same with suicidal depression. A typical “happy person with few problems” is not going to understand suicidal depression well enough to help a suicidally depressed person to better cope with it; because the “happy people” do not understand it.
Some of us do “care” about the world, and the people in it… but many of us are incredibly bitter, jaded, cynical, /because of/ the world, and the people in it.
Your insinuative premise is that A) we don’t care, and B) not caring makes us “bad” … and that is both inaccurate and offensive.
It’s as if people think it’s okay to insult us for not caring about what those who cause us problems, demand we “care about.”
There is “a point” in caring about others. It’s just not one that’s easily explained. And it doesn’t matter whether or not there is “any point.” Caring doesn’t require a purpose. Likewise, suicide doesn’t mean we don’t care. It means we can’t deal with the way things are, knowing we can’t change it.
I’ll agree on the “save yourself” part, though.
Who would ever want to live a life in which you always need someone to “save” you? The self is the only one who can save the self.
^^Brilliant response (by clevername)
With the semi exception that i’m not so much “offended” but have pity – i believe the original poster is projecting his/her own feelings more than accurately describing the general attitude of the folks here.
I think a lot of people around here may care too much about others, their opinions and their actions and don’t focus on their own well being as much as they should.
dawg
Thanks Dawg. I actually agree with what you said about not “being offended,” but instead feeling a sense of pity.
There’s a subtle but important distinction to be made, here, in that, while i’m saying something “is offensive,” that doesn’t necessarily mean that “i feel offended.” Imagine Dr. Spock stating that he finds something inaccurate and offensive. I meant it in a more… clinical, vulcan, observational way. And i do often pity those who commit an offense borne of ignorance. Doing things that upset people, just because you don’t know any better, is pretty sad. Doing things that upset people, because you /don’t care to know/ any better, is “offensive.” I realize this is a quite common occurrence, and so unless it’s something serious, i rarely take it personally… though i still like to point out that certain things “are offensive,” so that, perhaps the person wants to know that, and will learn something, and choose to act differently in the future. Or, they will blatantly reject the lesson, drawing the line between us, and identifying themselves as someone who does not want to learn. And no one has time for people who don’t want to learn. While it’s tempting, i have no time for being personally offended by such offenses. I usually just chalk it up to “that’s just how people are,” frown in disappointment, shrug, and move on.
I’ve been feeling very frustrated lately. I’m seeing lots of evidence of a misguidance pandemic. I mean… i guess i always knew it was there, but ‘here’ it’s emphasized. It’s just more reinforcement for my very generalized theory that “misguidance leads to increased suffering.”
@clevername-
A very wise man once reminded me of the fact:
“Some men just want to watch the world burn!”
And I add to that:
Some men only feel the fire!
“misguidance leads to increased suffering.â€
I couldn’t agree more with your hypothesis here – I know from first hand experience … thankfully I had my epiphany on how to view things from a perspective that centers around me but yet has compassion for others provided they at least respond with a base level of respect, honor and civility – if they don’t, i refuse to internalize it (a point where many people go off the rails) – i simply reject and ignore the ungrateful folks and walk away without another thought or concern
in other words, don’t let negative people rent space in your head
Also, another important epiphany was that “Forgiveness” is most important for me than it ever will be for those i “give” it to. But way too many people hoard forgiveness like it’s gold bricks that people don’t deserve … and that might be true if forgiveness was more important for others than it is for self … but it really isn’t that way at all. But that concept runs counter to everything most of us have been taught all our lives thus making it difficult to “flip the script” on how forgiveness actually works.
Anyway – a lot of philosophies and view can be better understood in my posts and comments … you can lead a horse to water …
new world dawg
You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make it think? Is that how it goes? 🙂
I like the analogy of the blind leading the blind. Imagine getting directions on the street from a blind man, if you were lost, blind, and in unfamiliar territory. I suppose it’s possible the other blind man could help you find your way, but ultimately you’ll have to stumble along and figure it for yourself.
In order to respond to your statement, we must first consider what being suicidal means. Not everyone here is suicidal and if they are, not everyone is suicidal all of the time. I believe that to be suicidal you must actively be seeking out a way to die and it is your intention for this to be carried out within a reasonable amount of time. In my opinion, a person like that is going to be too preoccupied with ending their own life than saving someone else. This does not necessarily mean that they want to assist others in dying or that they are incapable of caring for other people. It does not prevent them from making helpful comments or giving advice. Those that contemplate suicide are not always selfish in doing so (there have been many posts on this).
Once you have established what being suicidal is, you then have to consider whether a person deemed suicidal can be helped online. Suicide hotlines exist for a reason. People standing on the edge of tall buildings or with a gun to their head have been talked down. A forum like this (or at least the way it was before the new mods took over) can help distract a suicidal person long enough for their state of mind to alter or circumstances that brought them here to change. Which leads me on to another point; what is help? They believe they are helping by deleting posts when in fact if anything it has the opposite affect. I’ll come back to power, authority and personal benefit in the next paragraph. People generally overemphasise the help you get or receive online but it would be unfair to say it hasn’t saved at least one person’s life.
Going back to what I said about suicidal people giving help, it’s appropriate to consider peoples motives. Why do people offer help. If a non-suicidal person offers help because they somehow gain the kind of gratification you get from saving the world or doing a good deed or because they like making friends then it is mutually beneficial. Similarly, a suicidal person can benefit by offering to help somebody else. It’s not just about the benefit derived from receiving support but the sense of purpose in thinking you’ve made someones life better or made a friend.
Of course, nobody has all the answers and that doesn’t depend on whether you are suicidal or not. I know plenty of stupid people who have never been suicidal and I’d never follow there advice on anything. Equally, you aren’t always going to get a high quality response to your post that makes you think or makes you feel. There are also plenty of non-suicidal’s that have absolutely no regard for anyone except themselves.
People are suicidal for different reasons. The reasons as well as their personality and experience will determine the extent to which they are able to take advantage of the support they give or receive.
I disagree with the “blind leading the blind” analogy fundamentally … this analogy assume everyone has the same problem … that is fundamentally incorrect … everyone has a similar symptom to a problem – depression/suicidal …. but they arrived there from vastly different root issues … in other words they are not all “blind” as it were.
now if we were to say something like “the handicapped leading the handicapped”, that would be infinitely more accurate since that would include every handicap across the spectrum – including, but not limited to, the blind. In this context – the varied handicaps can be a hindrance to some but they’d still have abilities that a differently handicapped person did not.
The problem comes when the blind person does not ask the sighted but legless person for assistance – if you willfully reject the assistance from those who are able or who may otherwise have insight, your chance to move forward becomes much more difficult if not impossible … so …
you can lead a horse to water … but you can’t make him think or drink or anything else … it is now and always has been the choice of the “horse” as to his direction
reiteration dawg
I disagree too. Suicidal people can, and are strongly willing, to help others like them. The fact of the matter is that those who have not seen the dark side, and experienced it themselves, can not help them. They have no clue how to relate to what they feel or how they think. I find it easier to talk to someone who’s suicidal like I am than to someone who thinks they know what I’m talking about because they read that story or saw that movie. When I talk to people who aren’t like me, they always say, “Stay strong!!! It’ll get better if you just try harder.” But people who understand what I’m going through talk to me about what’s happening and give me advice that actually helps.
.
There will be people (note, not all) who are [truly] suicidal and where their mind has reached that state where ‘committing suicide’ is perceived as being ‘necessary’ — in which state they will not have the psychological (/ emotional) wherewithal / capacity to _care_ for others… A lot of _suicides_ ( and those which have been thoroughly contemplated [ as deemed so by the individual, within their ‘capacity’ ] ) will have as an integral component the sense (‘understanding’ [according to the individual’s processing], even) that the ‘world’ has ‘failed’ them … even that no one is truly concerned about / cares for them ( ‘hence’ “there is no point in caring for others… save yourself”).
.
Only the committed can know for sure
The rest of the world continues to speculate
Try as they will to relate
Failing to achieve real compassion
Relating to a computer screen in place of relativity
The absence of understanding breathes deep
I’m not saying that everyone’s depression is the same, i’m saying that someone with the same problem is most likely to understand how to cope with it, whereas someone who does not understand that problem, cannot. The blind can lead the blind through their blindness, better than can the sighted. The deaf can lead the deaf through their deafness, better than those who hear.
Your interpretation seems to assume that “all depression is blindness” when that is not what i was saying, nor the point of the analogy. I just thought there was an apt comparison to a long-established phrase. Person with problem-A is likely more capable of helping another person with problem-A, than someone who cannot understand problem-A as someone who has experienced it, can.
The reason “the blind leading the blind” was relevant, and is a better descriptor than the overly-generalized “handicapped leading the handicapped,” is because of the specificity. There are copious different types and degrees of “handicapped.” Whose to say one “handicapped” understands another, of an entirely different nature? That was the point. People with /the same problem/ are more likely to understand each other, and be better able to help each other cope. “Suicidal depression” in this case is a sort of blanket term… but is similar enough that even when it occurs for different reasons, the experience of it is quite similar, as opposed to, say, a blind person versus a quadriplegic. People with the same or similar problems, are better able to understand and assist each other, due to knowledge that only those who experience those problems, will have.
Sometimes, the blind need help that only the sighted can give. In this case, i was referring to help that only another blind person would be able to give, because the sighted cannot “truly understand” the experience of blindness.